# Automated government systems under the forensic computer expert's microscope: problems and solutions Oleg Bezik · Digital Research Laboratory Slides · https://2025.moscow-forensics-day.workers.dev/en/slides/18-bezik-avtomatizirovannye-sistemy An English version of the Russian deck shown in the recording: the text set by the authors is translated and redrawn in place, everything captured from a screen is left as it was. --- ## Page 1 — 08:14:16 ЛАБОРАТОРИЯ ЦИФРОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ MK> ИСТЕ М Automated government systems under the forensic computer expert's microscope: problems and solutions MOSCOW FORENSICS DAY '25 11-12 September 2025 Pulsar Space ## Page 2 — 08:14:44 2 ЛАБОРАТОРИЯ ЦИФРОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ We are a team of professional experts in applying specialized IT knowledge in court proceedings Our experts are people who stood at the origins of forensic computer examination in Russia, international professionals in computer forensics, information security and the disclosure of digital data in court, PhDs and lecturers at the country's leading technical universities Since 2016 we have carried out complex computer-technical examinations and advised on applying IT knowledge in court proceedings Since 2024 we develop IT solutions for comparing the source code of computer programs Since 2025 we are an IT company (No. 70081 in the register of accredited organizations) 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 3 — 08:15:12 3 Oleg Bezik Founder and CEO of Digital Research Laboratory Education: Bauman MSTU, Forensic Science, specialist degree, 2014 Bauman MSTU, Information Technology, master's degree, 2016 Certificates: • ISACA's Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) • EC-Council's Computer Hacking Forensic Investigator (CHFI) • ACEDS's Certified E-Discovery Specialist (CEDS) ## Page 4 — 08:17:02 What is an AS 4 Automated system - a system consisting of personnel and a set of tools automating their activity, implementing the information technology for performing established functions Per GOST 34.003-90 Well-known examples: GAS Gosuslugi GAS Pravosudie GAS Legal Statistics GAS Vybory ASK NDS Unified Biometric System Unified Information System for Procurement 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 5 — 08:18:52 What is an SKTE 5 Forensic examination 1. a procedural action 2. appointed by an authorized body (court, investigator, inquiry officer) 3. is an examination and the preparation of an expert report on the questions put 4. the expert report has the force of evidence 5. requires specialized knowledge in some field of science, technology, art or craft It is a way of bringing specialized non-legal knowledge into court proceedings Forensic computer examination (SKTE) - is a genus of forensic examinations, belongs to the class of engineering and technical examinations, performed on digital data, software and computer hardware 2025 г. ODO Лаборатория ифровых и Все пра ## Page 6 — 08:20:16 6 When an AS SKTE is needed Commercial court cases Cases on the recovery of funds 1) Check that the work to develop/modify the AS meets the contract/agreement requirements Determine the cause of failure of the AS or of its individual components and modules 2) Purpose of the SKTE: Determine whether critical or irremediable defects are present Assess the cost of the completed/uncompleted work on developing the AS 4) 5) Assess the cost of remedying the AS defects Example cases: • А40-4549/23-27-32 • А40-278316/21-114-2040 • А40-210136/22 • А07-10804/19 • А40-41613/24-126-318 • А40-238914/22-5-1798 • А40-196951/2023 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 7 — 08:24:00 7 Sample questions for an AS SKTE Do the work results delivered to the customer meet the requirements of the state contract/agreement, the technical specification and the detailed specification? What is the cost of the work actually performed that meets the contract/agreement requirements? Critical defect - a defect whose presence makes using the product for its intended purpose practically impossible or impermissible* If there are defects, are they critical? If there are defects, are they remediable/irremediable? How much money will be needed to remedy such defects? What amount of the contract/agreement price covers work of inadequate quality? Irremediable defect - a defect whose remedying is technically impossible and economically expedient* * Per GOST 15467-79 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 8 — 08:27:44 Difficulties in examining an AS No common methodologies - always creativity Algorithm in theory Algorithm implemented in code 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 9 — 08:29:15 Difficulties in examining an AS Huge volume of objects to examine 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 10 — 08:31:28 Difficulties in examining an AS Colleagues, we can attend the examination HOORAY! Examination is held in person and can last very long But the examination will take 2 years 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 11 — 08:34:13 Tips for preparing for an AS SKTE 11 1 Prepare the objects for examination The contract/agreement text AS documentation AS source code The running AS MY FACE 2 Prepare questions for the expert Questions on the AS meeting the contract/agreement requirements Questions on the defects present: critical, irremediable Questions on the cost of the work done/of the rework 3 Choose the experts Experts have the relevant education Experts have the relevant experience WHEN I'M GIVEN GREAT ADVICE 2025 Digital Research Laboratory LLC All rights reserved ## Page 12 — 08:35:16 ЛАБОРАТОРИЯ ЦИФРОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ CHECKLIST On preparing for a forensic computer examination of an automated system