# The value of security tools: what we wouldn't have if we had everything Nikita Vyugin · MKO Systems Slides · https://2025.moscow-forensics-day.workers.dev/en/slides/13-vyugin-instrumenty-ib An English version of the Russian deck shown in the recording: the text set by the authors is translated and redrawn in place, everything captured from a screen is left as it was. --- ## Page 1 — 05:49:38 THE VALUE OF SECURITY TOOLS: WHAT WE WOULDN'T HAVE IF WE HAD EVERYTHING ## Page 2 — 05:50:11 Словосочетания "кибер-зрелость" придуманное ИБ-маркетологами, чаще всего, звучит как: "У вас нет 5 млн. рублей за наш ВЕЛИКИЙ продукт? Ну так вы еще не доросли! Идите отседова, не мешайте торговать!" 7 100 5 • 756 23:41 Leave a Comment © BEHOLDERISHERE ## Page 3 — 05:50:44 DASARCASM ## Page 4 — 05:51:54 MYTHS OF REASONABLENESS AND MATURITY ## Page 5 — 05:53:19 ANTIVIRUS DLP Antivirus finds, blocks and removes malware. Antivirus is the basic level of endpoint protection: users, office machines, servers. The very first step in a cybersecurity strategy. EDR/XDR SIEM SOAR SOC DFIR ## Page 6 — 05:54:43 ANTIVIRUS NUANCES: False positives DLP False sense of security EDR/XDR Limited detection SIEM Poor integration with other security tools • BYOD SOAR Difficulties in investigating incidents SOC DFIR ## Page 7 — 05:56:00 ANTIVIRUS DLP WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT ANTIVIRUS: Simple threats won't be blocked right away Higher load on other security systems EDR/XDR Increased risk of infection “from below” SIEM Loss of the basic level of compliance Financial and reputational consequences SOAR SOC DFIR ## Page 8 — 05:56:31 This is the foundation, the basics. If your company uses even one digital device — you need an antivirus. ## Page 9 — 05:58:01 ANTIVIRUS DATA LOSS PREVENTION/PROTECTION DLP The basic task of DLP is to prevent leaks of data (personal, financial, confidential) by controlling the channels. EDR/XDR SIEM WHEN IT IS USED: SOAR When compliance with GDPR, HIPAA, ISO 27001, FZ-152 etc. is required. SOC When the risk of insider or commercial information leaking is high. DFIR ## Page 10 — 05:59:04 ANTIVIRUS MAIN DIFFICULTIES OF RUNNING DLP IN CORPORATE SECURITY: DLP High demands on configuration and data classification EDR/XDR False positives and “noise” Negative user reaction SIEM Technical limitations SOAR Integration with business processes Leak channels evolve — constant re-tuning needed SOC Balance (reasonableness!!!!111!11!) in everything DFIR ## Page 11 — 06:00:07 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT DLP: DLP Higher risk of data leaks No control over transfer channels EDR/XDR Financial and reputational losses SIEM Breaking the law and fines No incident investigations! SOAR Insider attacks become possible SOC Hard to meet partners’ requirements DFIR ## Page 12 — 06:00:33 DLP is good and important! DLP put in “with the spare change” is bad — eats money, creates problems. ## Page 13 — 06:01:29 ANTIVIRUS DLP Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) — monitors PCs and servers, but does it a bit more interestingly than antivirus: it records process behaviour, network connections, script launches and so on. EDR/XDR SIEM Extended Detection and Response (XDR) — a larger-scale EDR. It uses the network, email, clouds etc. as data sources, correlates events across systems and provides a single console for management and investigation. SOAR SOC DFIR ## Page 14 — 06:03:00 ANTIVIRUS EDR/XDR NUANCES IN CORPORATE SECURITY: DLP Noise and alert overload Complex to deploy and configure EDR/XDR High demands on staff competence SIEM Integration with other systems Balance between security and user convenience SOAR Expensive to scale (and you will have to!!!) SOC DFIR ## Page 15 — 06:04:10 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT EDR/XDR: DLP Poor visibility of endpoints Late detection of incidents EDR/XDR Investigation difficulties (DFIR) SIEM Ineffective SOC Growing damage from attacks SOAR Failure to meet modern security standards SOC DFIR ## Page 16 — 06:04:48 EDR and XDR are powerful tools for protecting corporate infrastructure that provide a high level of security. But before deploying them it is important to weigh carefully all the pros and cons, and the company’s readiness for such changes. ## Page 17 — 06:06:02 ANTIVIRUS SECURITY INFORMATION & EVENT MANAGEMENT DLP EDR/XDR SIEM collects logs and stores events, applies correlation rules. SIEM IMPORTANT: SOAR SOC It does not respond automatically (unlike SOAR) and does not protect by itself — it detects and informs; it can take data from EDR, AV, network devices, DLP and other systems. DFIR ## Page 18 — 06:07:47 ANTIVIRUS THORNS ON THE WAY TO SIEM: DLP “Garbage” at the input Detailed rules have to be written for your infrastructure EDR/XDR SIEM You must be sure you have the resources for manual or automatic response to SIEM’s call, otherwise there is no point SOAR SOC DFIR ## Page 19 — 06:08:57 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT SIEM: DLP No single picture of security events Poor real-time visibility of attacks EDR/XDR SOC goes “blind” SIEM Investigations become hard (DFIR) Failure to meet requirements and standards SOAR SOC DFIR ## Page 20 — 06:09:41 At scale, without SIEM a company effectively loses the central brain of monitoring. All the other systems work, but each on its own, and the business has no full security picture. ## Page 21 — 06:12:40 ANTIVIRUS SECURITY ORCHESTRATION, AUTOMATION & RESPONSE DLP EDR/XDR SIEM SOAR is an automatic problem-shoveller. This system does not collect data itself, but it automates the response. WHAT AWAITS US? WE WANT SOAR! Complex to configure and integrate SOAR Writing playbooks Danger of automatic actions SOC DFIR Pushback from other teams Reality: SOAR has to interfere in other teams’ processes (sysadmins, IT, the support desk) SOAR ≠ artificial intelligence. SOAR will decide nothing by itself. It does not “think” ## Page 22 — 06:14:04 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT SOAR: DLP Slow response to incidents SOC overload and analyst burnout EDR/XDR More errors SIEM Uneven level of protection Difficulties in scaling SOAR Financial consequences SOC DFIR ## Page 23 — 06:15:05 ANTIVIRUS SECURITY OPERATION CENTER DLP EDR/XDR SOC is an information security monitoring centre. An organizational unit that receives signals from everywhere, sorts through them and responds accordingly. SIEM SOAR SOC DFIR GREAT AND TERRIBLE!!! ## Page 24 — 06:16:22 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT SOC: DLP Cost Shortage of decent staff EDR/XDR Flow of incidents and alert fatigue SIEM SOAR Complex integration of different systems Incident response — manual and slow Hard to run 24/7 SOC No business support Attacks evolve DFIR ## Page 25 — 06:17:25 ANTIVIRUS WHAT AWAITS US WITHOUT SOC: DLP No round-the-clock monitoring Slower response EDR/XDR No centralized picture of threats SIEM More undetected incidents SOAR Chaos in response Financial and reputational losses SOC No investigation expertise Difficulties with compliance DFIR ## Page 26 — 06:17:52 SOC is not an “option” but a necessary element of mature cyber defence at a certain scale. A successful SOC = a balance of technologies (SIEM, SOAR, EDR/XDR, DLP), processes and people. ## Page 27 — 06:18:47 ANTIVIRUS DIGITAL FORENSICS & INCIDENT RESPONSE DLP DFIR = investigation + incident response. SIEM Working with DFIR is like investigating an accident on a nuclear submarine, but a week later, from the wreckage, with no access to the log book, with management that wants the “topic closed by lunchtime”. SOC SOAR DFIR ## Page 28 — 06:20:11 ANTIVIRUS HERE TOO IT IS NOT SIMPLE: DLP No proper recording of information Time is critical EDR/XDR Huge experience required SIEM Myriads of complex tools (vendor + open source + home-brewed) SOAR High demands on data collection and storage SOAR DFIR ## Page 29 — 06:22:17 ANTIVIRUS MAYBE WE DON’T NEED IT? WE DO! DLP EDR/XDR The cause of incidents is unclear No certainty that the attack has been shut down No digital evidence SIEM SOAR Impossible to trace the attacker’s actions Trouble with regulators and law enforcement SOAR Growing business risks DFIR ## Page 30 — 06:23:59 CHEAT SHEET REMINDER: TECHNOLOGY / SYSTEM REAL-WORLD ANALOGUE EXPLANATION Antivirus (AV) A guard at the entrance with a metal detector Checks everyone coming in for weapons. Responds to known threats (signatures) EDR Cameras in every office + an analyst watching behaviour Watches what goes on inside, records strange actions, raises the alarm XDR A security system combining cameras, motion sensors, electronic locks etc. Centralized visibility — links behaviour at the entrance, in the offices, in the car park SIEM A control room with logs and an event archive Stores and analyses data from all systems: who came in, what they opened, where they went SOAR An auto-response system: alarm → door locked → guards called On detecting a threat it runs pre-programmed actions DLP An X-ray at the exit checking whether secret documents are being carried out Makes sure nobody carries confidential data out SOC A guard room staffed around the clock The team watches all the signals, responds to alarms, coordinates actions DFIR An investigation team after the incident: analysis of prints and logs, questioning the guards Investigates what happened, how the thief got in, what they stole and how to prevent it in future ## Page 31 — 06:24:58 INSTEAD OF A CONCLUSION: Don’t fall for bare advertising Assess, consult, communicate, count everything in figures (don’t want to think — go to the pentesters) Without a sensible approach any tool (even antivirus) is just an expensive toy that eats money and nerves ## Page 32 — 06:25:45 THANK YOU CONTACTS: +7 (495) 909-92-78 clients@mko-systems.ru mko-security.ru